We all have that one friend who’s super serious about their skincare regimen. They have a whole cabinet full of oils, creams, serums, and cleansers and are always the first to know about the next big skincare must-have. But for some of us (myself included) it’s a miracle that we even remember to put on moisturizer.
So when I started venturing out of my comfort zone to find a good under-eye cream, I took to Amazon reviews with suggestions from those skincare-literate friends to find the best eye cream that was natural, too! With all the different brands and products online, it can be tough to find a high-quality product that’s good for the environment and your skin.
Whether you have some dark circles under your eyes or are starting to notice some crow’s feet, we’ve compiled a list of the best natural eye cream available on Amazon and Etsy.
Andalou Naturals Coconut Water Eye Cream
For a lightweight, anti-aging eye cream, check out this coconut water option from Andalou Naturals. Leaping Bunny cruelty-free certified and Non-GMO Project verified, this eye cream includes skin-friendly enzymes and vitamin C to brighten dark under-eye circles.
Reviewers on Amazon mention that this eye cream is a good option for sensitive skin, and works well to reduce puffiness.
Alba Botanica Green Tea Eye Cream
I love Alba Botanica, but many of their products are fruit-based, and I usually break out when I use fruit products on my skin. When I found this green tea option, however, I knew I had to try it! What I love about this eye cream is that it’s more of a gel rather than a cream, and I find it absorbs into my skin really well without leaving it greasy.
The scent is much more subtle than some of Alba Botanica’s other products, and I’ve definitely noticed that my under-eye puffiness is reduced when I apply it regularly. The formula is free of parabens, phthalates, and sulfates and the ingredients are 100% vegetarian.
Amazon reviewers also find that this eye gel does a good job of reducing under-eye puffiness and smoothing out crow’s feet. Another reviewer mentions that this is a must-have for hard-working mamas.
Avalon Organics Intense Defense Eye Cream
If I wasn’t sensitive to citrus, I would definitely have this eye cream in my skincare arsenal! I love Avalon’s other products, so I can bet that this would be a high-quality, natural under-eye cream for those with less sensitive skin.
This eye cream is infused with vitamin C to brighten up dull skin and reduce under-eye puffiness. The formula is free of parabens, synthetic fragrances, phthalates, and sulfates, and is Leaping Bunny cruelty-free certified.
As I anticipated, there are a few reviewers on Amazon who also mention this isn’t the best eye cream for sensitive skin, and it caused them to break out. However, others with more neutral skin mention that this cream makes their skin feel moisturized and look bright.
No B.S. Skincare Caffeine Eye Cream With Hyaluronic Acid
Made with caffeine and quinoa seed extract to enhance circulation and reduce discoloration, this eye cream from No B.S. Skincare is definitely on my wish list!
It’s free of parabens, phthalates, and sulfates and works to minimize dark circles, reduce puffiness, and brighten your skin.
This eye cream has an overall review of 5 stars on Amazon, and reviewers rave about how much brighter their eye area has become. One reviewer mentions that this cream reduces under-eye darkness while simultaneously smoothing their skin. Another reviewer mentions that she works nights and found that this eye cream is the best at removing dark circles.
Triple Carrot Night Repair Eye Cream
Featuring evening primrose seed oil, pumpkin seed oil, carrot seed oil, and sunflower seed oil, this eye cream from Etsy is a highly moisturizing addition to your skincare regimen. Each 1-ounce bottle is handmade and has a creamy texture that leaves your skin feeling hydrated and smooth.
Antioxidant-rich ingredients like carrot seed oil, carrot root extract, and jojoba oil work to slow down the process of aging by controlling the production of free radicals.
Reviewers of this eye cream love the creamy consistency of this product and how hydrating it is. One reviewer mentions that after using this cream at night, the next morning her eyes were smoother and brighter.
Taralee Eye Cream
Handmade with ingredients like aloe vera, jojoba oil, green tea extract, and cucumber extract, this eye cream from Etsy is vegan, nontoxic, and cruelty-free. The cream has a lightweight consistency and is created with dark circles and eye bags in mind.
One reviewer mentioned that with a few days of patience, she started to see the dark circles under her eyes reduced.