Healthy Habits WomandrinkingMilkviaSstock

Published on February 10th, 2012 | by Liz Thompson

5

Got Calcium?

Let’s talk about a controversial dietary staple…Dairy.  Is it as good for us as the experts say?

Continuing our discussion on eating healthy and how to get the nutrients you need from food, this week I’d like to talk about a controversial dietary staple…Dairy.  So many of you fantastic and knowledgeable FGS readers responded to the posts on supplements and raw food-ing, and I am reaching out to you again on this one.

Really, for me it does not boil down to a love of milk and cheese, I could live without either just fine.  It is about calcium and making sure I am getting enough of it.  But we want the calcium that goes into our bodies to be “good” calcium, and I am still unclear on whether or not calcium supplements are that great for our health.

As women, we are told repeatedly by doctors and health experts that we have to get a certain amount of calcium to avoid osteoporosis later in life.  The recommended daily allowance for calcium for women ages 19-50 is 1,000 mg, up to 1,200 mg for those over 50.

But what is the best source of calcium?

Your doctor probably asks if you are taking a calcium supplement at your annual visit, right?  But I have read that the calcium in supplements can build up in the arteries, definitely not a good thing if this is true.

The latest news on the subject is that you are safe from this build up if you take your calcium supplement with a vitamin D supplement.  Really?!  This could be completely true, or it could be a big maybe because experts are still unsure.

I’m not willing to take the chance and have decided to get my calcium from food.  Namely, cow’s milk.  Why cow’s milk?  Because almond milk or even orange juice that has added calcium is just as good as taking a supplement.  And then you do not even know anything about the quality of the supplement.

So, I was fine with my three glasses of calcium a day.  That is until I read The Beauty Detox Solution by Kimberly Snyder.  In the book she explains that it is difficult for our bodies to digest animal products, especially dairy.  As a matter of fact, in the first phase of her plan she suggests eliminating dairy from your diet completely while still eating a small amount of meat (if you are a meat-eater).  Wow, eliminate dairy before meat…that got my attention.

In TBDS Kimberly explains that not only is dairy very difficult for our human bodies to break down and process (because of the high content of the proteins casein and whey) but also has links to autism and certain types of cancer.  She states findings from studies funded by the National Institues of Health and the American Cancer Society which found “a strong correlation between casein intake and the promotion of cancer cell growth when exposed to carcinogens”.   So dairy ups your risk of cancer?  Ugh.  The book goes on to say that osteoporosis is actually seen more often in those who consume higher amounts of dairy.

Kimberly, like many vegans and raw foodies, promotes getting your calcium through a plant-based diet.   Kale, cruciferous veg (broccoli, cauliflower), collards, cucumber, romaine, spinach, sesame seeds and bok choy are said to be good sources of calcium.  And I am fine with getting my daily intake of calcium from veggies.

So, here is my big question:  How do you know if you are getting enough calcium from the veg you eat?  It is easy to pour a few glasses of milk a day, but how can we be sure we are eating enough of these vegetables to get the perfect amount of calcium.  I like my vegetables, but am not having an easy time of being a complete vegan, let me tell you.

All of this leads to possibly the biggest question of all:  Do we really need as much calcium as “they” say we do?

This calcium thing has me confused and I would love to hear what your voices have to say about it!

{Woman drinking milk image via Shutterstock}


Get non-toxic and cruelty free beauty and health tips from FeelGoodStyle!




Tags: , , , , , ,


About the Author

I am an organic beauty expert, writer, and mom of two young environmentalists who can already spot a toxic product when they see one. Read more about me at Organic Beauty Source.com, and find me on , Twitter, Pinterest, and Facebook.



  • http://glueandglitter.com/main Becky Striepe

    That’s a great question, Liz, and definitely one I think about quite a bit as a vegan. The dairy industry has done an excellent job of marketing milk products as the best source of calcium, but as Snyder points out in her book, it’s so untrue. Many people – vegan, vegetarian, and omnivore alike – don’t get enough calcium in our day to day, and you can get calcium from plant-based sources like you mention in your post. I load up on leafy greens, cruciferous veggies, and fortified foods, and so far so good!

    We have some posts over at Eat Drink Better on vegan calcium sources. This one might be helpful:
    http://eatdrinkbetter.com/2011/01/19/eating-vegan-calcium/
    I also highly recommend the Vegetarian Resource Group for vegan nutrition info. This has a lot of good stuff:
    http://www.vrg.org/nutrition/calcium.htm

  • Mary

    Thanks for this important post Liz. I’ve been resisting my calcium supplement lately – just can’t force myself to take – yet at 54 have a little bone thinning. Lot’s of mornings I start out with a kale/spinach/dandelion green smoothie and try to get greens with lunch and dinner. I am working on ridding my diet of animal protein – cheese is the most difficult to let go of.
    I look forward to following the discussion on this post.

    Best,
    Mary

  • nochemicalcosmeticsdotcom

    I love all your articles, Liz, and this one really got my attention as I believe that the dairy marketing for calcium is a ‘crock’! As for calcium supplements, our bodies can’t digest ground-up rocks, but plants can, and we can get the calcium from the plants we eat. Grass juices should not be over looked as a great supplement, especially for alkalising (but that is another topic!) But again, human stomachs are different from cows’ and we can’t digest the cellulose fibre. We need the grass juice. I do know of a certified organic powdered grass juice supplement I have been enjoying for almost a year now, to help boost my calcium intake as well as a general superfood. At a few years of 60, as my mother likes to remind me! … I look for logical solutions and the dairy industry has been exposed as promoting untruths!

  • http://OrganicBeautySource.com Liz Thompson

    Thank you all for your help with the calcium question. Eat Drink Better(link above in Becky’s comment) is a super great resource for all things vegan, including getting your plant based calcium. Don’t know that I will ever be completely vegan, but the info I’ve seen lately makes a very good case for giving up meat and dairy.

  • Pingback: Vegan Essentials: Finding Nontoxic Vegan Cosmetics

Back to Top ↑