The Best Organic Mascara Mashup

The Best Organic Mascara Mashup

Organic mascara mashups seem to be sort of a thing these days. I seriously stumble across a new one every week, it seems.

Why mascara? Why not blusher or lipstick mashups?

Because mascara is trickier. Most women love their chosen mascara and aren’t excited to try something new. If it ain’t broke sorta thing.

We want our mascara to lengthen, thicken, add deeper color, and (possibly most of all) stay put. I’ve worn mascaras that disappear over the course of a day and even tried one that stung my eyes when it ran off. Not ok.

So, in keeping with the organic mascara mashup trend, I thought it was time for a fresh review here at Feelgood. Here are my recently tried, current faves, and some not-so-new tried-and-trues. Choose any of these and you won’t have to worry about nasty chemicals, irritation, clumpiness, or spider eyes.

RMS Beauty Volumizing Mascara By one of my top favorite brands, this mascara is nice and smooth. Perfect for light, daytime color.

100% Pure Fruit Pigmented Mascara in Black Tea I did not expect to like this mascara as much as I do. But I do. It is the perfect consistency (smooth but not too thin) and thickens lashes. It also lasts a long time.

Lavera Volume Mascara in Black My longtime mascara bud, Lavera Volume Mascara is one I always keep on hand. It is smooth, silky, lengthens lashes and is super gentle. Love this one.

Dr Hauschka Mascara in Black The pies de resistance of organic mascaras. This one is the show stopper. It lengthens, defines, adds volume, and comes in the best shade of black of any mascara, ever.


[Mascara wand image via Shutterstock]

This post contains affiliate links. It is one of the ways we make money. Just know, we only recommend products we 100% believe in!

Written by Liz Thompson

I am an organic beauty expert, writer, and mom of two young environmentalists who can already spot a toxic product when they see one. Read more about me at Organic Beauty, and find me on , Twitter, Pinterest, and Facebook.

Fall Skin Photo

Secrets to Healthy Fall Skin: Tips + Tricks to Keep Your Glow When the Temp Drops

3 DIY Scarves for Fall

3 DIY Scarves for Fall